As the global population approaches the nine billion mark, the demand for sustainable and ethical sources of protein is more urgent than ever. The environmental, ethical, and health issues surrounding traditional meat production have spurred significant advancements in plant-based meat alternatives and cellular agriculture. These technologies represent a rapidly growing field that seeks to mimic or replace animal-derived meat products using plant ingredients or lab-grown cells. Cellular agriculture, in particular, is emerging as a revolutionary approach with the potential to disrupt the traditional meat industry and contribute to a more sustainable food system.
1. Understanding Cellular Agriculture and Plant-Based Meats
In the quest to create sustainable meat alternatives, cellular agriculture and plant-based meat products have emerged as pioneering fields in food biotechnology. While both aim to reduce reliance on traditional livestock farming, they approach the production of meat-like products through different means and technologies. Each offers unique advantages and faces distinct challenges, making them complementary solutions to the environmental, ethical, and health concerns associated with conventional meat.
Cellular Agriculture: Cultivating Meat from Cells
Cellular Agriculture involves the production of animal-based products, such as meat, dairy, and leather, through cell culture rather than by raising and slaughtering animals. In meat production, this approach involves harvesting animal cells (such as muscle cells) and placing them in a nutrient-rich, controlled environment that simulates the conditions within a living organism. Through precise control over the environment, scientists can stimulate cell growth and differentiation, enabling these cells to multiply and form tissue structures resembling muscle and fat—key components of real meat.
The field of cellular agriculture for meat production is also commonly referred to as cultured meat, in vitro meat, or lab-grown meat. The end goal is to create a product that is biologically and structurally identical to conventional meat, delivering the same taste, texture, and nutritional profile. Cellular agriculture aims to replicate the natural processes of muscle development, but outside the body of an animal.
Key Processes in Cellular Agriculture
Cell Isolation and Selection: The first step involves selecting and isolating the ideal types of cells for cultivation, often focusing on muscle and fat cells due to their key roles in flavor and texture. Stem cells, which have the ability to differentiate into various cell types, are typically used because of their regenerative properties.
Nutrient-Rich Growth Media: Cells require a specialized growth medium to thrive and multiply, providing the essential nutrients (proteins, carbohydrates, amino acids, fats, and growth factors) needed for cell development. Traditionally, fetal bovine serum (FBS) was used in research, but ethical and cost concerns have led to the development of alternative, plant-based or synthetic growth media.
Bioreactors for Large-Scale Production: Bioreactors are vessels that provide the controlled environment required for cell growth, supplying cells with oxygen, nutrients, and mechanical stimulation to mimic natural tissue formation. These large-scale bioreactors are crucial for commercial production, and innovations in their design are essential to improve scalability and cost-efficiency.
Tissue Structuring and Texture Engineering: To create a meat product that not only looks but also feels like traditional meat, cellular agriculture must replicate the intricate structure of muscle fibers. Scaffolds—3D structures made from biodegradable or edible materials—support cells as they grow, allowing them to form the fibrous, layered textures characteristic of meat. Recent advances focus on creating scaffolds that replicate the alignment and density of muscle fibers in a natural cut of meat.
Plant-Based Meat Alternatives: Leveraging Plant Proteins for Meat Mimicry
Unlike cellular agriculture, plant-based meat alternatives rely on plant-derived proteins and ingredients to simulate the sensory qualities of animal meat. This approach has been evolving for decades, with early versions of meat substitutes primarily targeting vegetarians and vegans. However, advancements in food science and consumer demand have transformed the field, resulting in products that appeal to a broader audience, including meat-eaters and flexitarians.
Plant-based meat products are crafted through a meticulous process that combines various plant proteins, fats, and other ingredients to closely mimic the taste, appearance, and mouthfeel of traditional meat. Leading companies like Impossible Foods and Beyond Meat have popularized these products by focusing on sensory aspects such as taste, juiciness, and the red color of raw meat, which changes upon cooking.
Key Components and Techniques in Plant-Based Meat Production
Protein Sourcing: A variety of plant sources are used to extract the proteins that serve as the base for plant-based meats. Soy, pea, wheat, and even mycoproteins (derived from fungi) are common sources, chosen for their high protein content and versatile textures. Pea protein, for example, is used by Beyond Meat due to its neutral taste and high nutritional value.
Heme and Flavor Development: One of the most significant advancements in plant-based meats is the incorporation of heme, a molecule that is abundant in animal blood and muscle and is responsible for the characteristic “meaty” taste. Impossible Foods has engineered a plant-derived form of heme, called soy leghemoglobin, which gives its products a similar flavor profile and red color that mimics the look of raw meat. This molecule is crucial to creating an authentic taste experience for consumers.
Extrusion Technology for Texture: Creating the fibrous texture of meat has been one of the biggest challenges for plant-based meat developers. Extrusion technology is used to heat, pressurize, and align plant proteins to mimic the fibrous structure of animal muscle. High-moisture extrusion, in particular, has enabled the development of products that better replicate the chewiness and mouthfeel of traditional meat.
Fats and Juiciness: Animal fats contribute significantly to the flavor and juiciness of meat, so plant-based alternatives need to replicate this as well. Plant-based fats, such as coconut oil and sunflower oil, are commonly used to mimic the melting behavior of animal fat during cooking, contributing to the overall juiciness and mouthfeel of the product.
Distinctions and Complementary Roles of Cellular Agriculture and Plant-Based Meat
While cellular agriculture and plant-based meats share the goal of reducing animal agriculture’s environmental impact, they offer different experiences for consumers and hold unique positions in the alternative protein market:
Biological Similarity: Cellular agriculture aims to produce products that are identical at the cellular level to real meat, appealing to consumers who desire a product that is fundamentally the same as traditional meat in terms of both structure and nutrition. Plant-based meats, though remarkably similar in taste and texture, remain distinct in terms of nutritional profile, often containing lower cholesterol and higher fiber content.
Production Complexity and Cost: Plant-based meat alternatives are currently more economical to produce than cultured meats, which still face high production costs due to the complex processes involved in cell culturing and bioreactor maintenance. Plant-based meats are also easier to scale and therefore more accessible to consumers.
Nutritional and Functional Customization: Cellular agriculture offers the potential to control and optimize nutritional content precisely, potentially allowing for the production of meat with adjusted levels of fats, vitamins, or amino acids. Plant-based meats are already able to cater to specific dietary needs, with some products fortified with vitamins, fiber, and omega-3 fatty acids.
2. Motivation for Plant-Based and Cultured Meat
The development of plant-based and cultured meat alternatives is driven by pressing environmental, ethical, health, and food security concerns associated with traditional animal agriculture. As the demand for meat continues to rise worldwide, especially in developing regions, alternative protein sources have gained attention as viable solutions to many of the challenges posed by livestock farming. Here, we explore in detail the motivations behind the rise of these innovative meat alternatives.
1. Environmental Sustainability
Traditional livestock farming is a resource-intensive industry that has a significant impact on the planet. It contributes heavily to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, deforestation, water scarcity, and biodiversity loss.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Livestock farming accounts for approximately 14.5% of all human-induced GHG emissions, primarily due to methane emissions from enteric fermentation in ruminants, manure management, and deforestation for pastureland. Methane is a potent GHG with a global warming potential many times higher than carbon dioxide. Plant-based and cultured meats, however, generate fewer emissions since they do not involve live animals, particularly methane-emitting livestock such as cows and sheep. Some studies estimate that cultivated meat could produce up to 92% fewer GHG emissions than conventional beef production.
Land and Water Use: Livestock farming is the single largest human land use, accounting for around 77% of agricultural land despite providing only about 18% of global calorie intake. The expansion of grazing land and feed crops contributes to deforestation, loss of ecosystems, and depletion of soil health. Producing plant-based meats, however, requires far less land—often by a factor of 10 or more. Similarly, water usage is substantially reduced; it takes approximately 15,000 liters of water to produce a kilogram of beef, while plant-based alternatives can use up to 95% less water. Cultured meat also has the potential to use fewer water resources, as cells are grown in highly controlled, efficient environments.
Preservation of Biodiversity: Industrial livestock farming is a major driver of habitat destruction, which threatens wildlife and biodiversity. Deforestation for grazing and feed crops reduces natural habitats, endangering species in affected regions. Cultured and plant-based meats, by minimizing land use, indirectly contribute to biodiversity conservation by reducing the need for land conversion and habitat destruction.
2. Animal Welfare
One of the central motivations behind cellular agriculture and plant-based meat production is the ethical treatment of animals. Traditional meat production relies on raising, confining, and slaughtering billions of animals annually, leading to significant animal suffering and exploitation. Intensive farming practices are associated with overcrowded and inhumane conditions, with limited or no opportunities for animals to express natural behaviors.
Elimination of Slaughter: Cellular agriculture, in particular, offers a way to produce real meat without the need to harm animals. By cultivating animal cells in a lab setting, cellular agriculture bypasses the need for slaughter, significantly reducing the ethical concerns surrounding animal welfare. This technology also holds the potential to produce other animal products, such as leather, gelatin, and dairy, without animal use.
Reduction in Industrial Farming Practices: The demand for animal products drives the expansion of factory farms, where animals are often raised in confined spaces with minimal care. These conditions can lead to stress, injuries, and diseases among animals. By reducing the demand for animal farming, plant-based and cultured meats help decrease the prevalence of such practices, promoting more humane approaches to food production.
Potential for Humane Labeling: For consumers concerned about animal welfare, the availability of plant-based and lab-grown meat options allows them to make ethical food choices without compromising their diet preferences. This aligns with the growing societal shift toward compassion in food production, where consumers increasingly value transparency and ethical sourcing.
3. Health Benefits
Both plant-based and cultured meats offer potential health advantages over conventional meat, particularly in terms of reduced risks related to fat content, antibiotic use, and contaminants.
Lower in Saturated Fats and Cholesterol: Plant-based meat alternatives, often made with plant proteins like soy, pea, or wheat, typically contain less saturated fat and cholesterol compared to red meats like beef and pork. High levels of saturated fat and cholesterol in animal products have been linked to an increased risk of cardiovascular diseases, obesity, and other health conditions. Replacing red meat with plant-based options can support healthier heart function and reduce the risk of chronic illnesses associated with high meat consumption.
Antibiotic-Free Production: Antibiotics are widely used in industrial animal farming to promote growth and prevent disease in overcrowded conditions. Overuse of antibiotics in livestock contributes to the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, a major global health concern. Cultured meat is grown in sterile conditions and does not require antibiotics, reducing the risk of antibiotic resistance. Plant-based meat production also does not involve antibiotics, making both alternatives safer options in this regard.
Absence of Pathogens and Contaminants: Animal-derived meat can carry pathogens like Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria, which can lead to foodborne illnesses. These pathogens typically result from contamination during processing, transportation, or handling. Plant-based and cultured meats, produced in controlled environments, have a reduced risk of contamination. Cultured meat, especially, is grown in sterile bioreactors, making it less susceptible to bacterial pathogens found in conventional meat.
Fortification Opportunities: Both plant-based and cultured meats offer the potential for fortification with essential nutrients, making them more nutritionally versatile. Plant-based options can be enriched with vitamins (e.g., B12, often lacking in vegan diets) and minerals to match the nutritional profile of animal products. Similarly, cultured meat could be engineered to include beneficial compounds, such as omega-3 fatty acids, enhancing the health profile of these products.
4. Food Security
As the global population continues to grow, so does the demand for sustainable food sources. Food security is a key driver for plant-based and cultured meat development, particularly in regions with limited access to arable land, clean water, and other resources.
Efficient Resource Use: By requiring fewer resources—land, water, and energy—plant-based and cultured meats offer a more efficient approach to food production. This could be particularly beneficial in countries facing resource constraints or harsh environmental conditions, allowing for local production and reducing dependence on imports. Cellular agriculture, for example, could enable the production of meat in urban areas or regions with limited agricultural space, contributing to food security and resilience.
Reduced Impact of Climate Events: Traditional animal farming is vulnerable to climate events such as droughts, floods, and temperature extremes, which can disrupt food supply chains and lead to shortages. Cultured meat, produced indoors in bioreactors, is less affected by these external factors, offering a more reliable food source in the face of climate change. Controlled environments in cellular agriculture and the resilience of plant-based protein crops make these alternatives more stable and adaptable under adverse climate conditions.
Supply Chain Resilience: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed vulnerabilities in the global food supply chain, particularly within the meat industry. Supply disruptions due to worker shortages, processing plant closures, and transportation challenges underscored the need for decentralized and resilient food systems. Plant-based and cultured meat production, with their potential for smaller-scale, distributed production, offer an alternative to centralized, large-scale animal farms, promoting local and more resilient food systems.
Affordable Protein Access: As technology improves and production scales up, the cost of plant-based and cultured meats is expected to decrease, making these alternatives more accessible to lower-income populations. Affordable access to high-quality, sustainable protein could play a vital role in addressing malnutrition and protein deficiencies in vulnerable communities.
3. Technological Advances in Cellular Agriculture for Meat Production
A. Cell Culturing Techniques
The core process in cellular agriculture for meat production involves cultivating animal cells outside the animal. Advances in cell culturing have focused on creating the ideal environment for these cells to grow and differentiate into muscle fibers, fat cells, and connective tissue, mimicking natural meat structure. Key areas of focus include:
- Scaffold Development: Scaffolds are materials that provide a 3D structure for cells to grow on, which is essential for producing the complex texture of meat. Biodegradable scaffolds made from plant or synthetic materials allow cells to grow in organized structures, improving the taste and mouthfeel of lab-grown meat.
- Bioreactors: Specialized bioreactors are used to scale up cell production, supplying them with oxygen, nutrients, and growth factors. Advances in bioreactor technology have enabled more efficient cell growth and differentiation, reducing production costs.
- Growth Media: Growth media provide the necessary nutrients for cells to proliferate and develop. Traditionally, fetal bovine serum (FBS) was used, but it is not sustainable or ethical. New plant-based or recombinant growth media are being developed to replace FBS, making the production process more ethical and economically viable.
B. Genome Editing and Cell Line Optimization
Scientists are using gene-editing technologies, such as CRISPR-Cas9, to enhance cell lines and improve their growth rates, nutritional profile, and texture. By editing specific genes, researchers can create cell lines that produce less fat or contain more of certain vitamins, catering to dietary needs and health preferences.
C. Flavor and Texture Enhancement
Creating plant-based meats with textures and flavors similar to traditional meat has been a significant challenge. Advances in this area include:
- Heme Production: Impossible Foods uses soy leghemoglobin, a heme protein derived from soy roots, to replicate the iron-rich flavor found in animal blood, making their burgers taste more like beef. Heme gives plant-based meats a juicy, umami taste and reddish color when cooked.
- Biomimicry and Sensory Optimization: Companies are studying the molecular structure of meat to mimic its sensory properties, including juiciness, fat distribution, and fiber alignment. Advances in computational modeling allow for precise replication of meat textures and flavors.
- Extrusion Techniques: High-moisture extrusion is a process that aligns plant proteins to create a fibrous structure similar to muscle tissue, enhancing the chewiness and texture of plant-based meats. Continuous innovation in extrusion technology has enabled companies to make plant proteins more meat-like.
4. Applications and Potential of Cellular Agriculture in the Meat Industry
The versatility of cellular agriculture is transforming the concept of meat production and expanding possibilities well beyond replicating traditional meat from livestock. This technology provides the flexibility to create unique products, customize nutritional content, and explore a broader range of animal species. As a result, cellular agriculture is not only a sustainable solution but also an innovative frontier in food technology, offering applications with far-reaching implications for conservation, nutrition, and personalization in food.
1. Production of Novel Meat Sources
One of the transformative aspects of cellular agriculture is its potential to produce meat from species that are not typically farmed for food. By cultivating cells from a wide variety of animals, scientists can create new types of meat products that might not be feasible to raise in traditional farming systems.
Exotic and Rare Meats: Cellular agriculture has opened the door to producing lab-grown meat from exotic or endangered species, such as bison, ostrich, or even lions and tigers. These products could be marketed as gourmet or novelty items, offering consumers the unique experience of trying meats that are otherwise rare or inaccessible. For instance, in 2018, scientists successfully cultured kangaroo meat, illustrating how cellular agriculture could diversify consumer choices without impacting wildlife populations.
Endangered Species for Conservation Awareness: In a unique approach to conservation, cellular agriculture has been used to culture meat from endangered animals, with the goal of raising awareness rather than consumption. For example, producing cultured meat from species like the northern white rhino or bluefin tuna can highlight the threats these animals face due to poaching and overfishing, encouraging consumers to think critically about biodiversity conservation. Additionally, by providing an alternative to wild-caught species, this technology can help reduce demand for endangered species in food markets.
Meat from Marine Species: Fish and other marine species can also be cultured in labs, addressing issues associated with overfishing and habitat destruction in marine ecosystems. Bluefin tuna, for example, is highly valued in culinary markets but is severely overfished. Cellular agriculture offers a solution by providing a sustainable source of bluefin tuna and other marine delicacies without further straining ocean resources.
2. Nutritionally Tailored Meat Products
One of the groundbreaking advantages of cellular agriculture is its potential to tailor the nutritional composition of meat. This customization could lead to healthier products that cater to specific dietary needs and preferences, providing benefits that traditional meat cannot offer.
Enrichment with Essential Nutrients: Cultured meat production allows scientists to modify the cellular environment and growth media, enabling the enhancement of specific nutrients. For example, cultured meat could be fortified with omega-3 fatty acids, which are typically found in fish and have known health benefits for heart and brain health. Similarly, vitamins like B12, which are often lacking in plant-based diets, could be incorporated directly into lab-grown meat.
Reduction of Saturated Fats: By adjusting the fat content during the cultivation process, cellular agriculture can produce meat with reduced levels of saturated fats, which have been associated with cardiovascular disease. Instead, healthier fats, such as unsaturated fats or omega-3s, could be incorporated, making the meat a healthier option. This capability allows for a balance of taste and nutrition without compromising the sensory qualities of meat.
Customized Protein Profiles: In addition to altering fat content, cellular agriculture offers the possibility to modify protein profiles, potentially enhancing the levels of specific amino acids based on dietary requirements. This customization could benefit individuals with specific nutritional needs or those looking to optimize protein intake for fitness and muscle recovery.
3. Meat Designed for Dietary Preferences and Restrictions
Cellular agriculture enables meat production that can be customized to meet various dietary preferences, such as kosher, halal, or allergen-free options, providing inclusivity and expanding access to high-quality protein for diverse consumer groups.
Religious and Cultural Requirements: Certain religious practices impose restrictions on meat consumption, such as halal and kosher dietary laws. Cellular agriculture can address these needs by producing meat under controlled conditions that comply with religious guidelines. For instance, cells can be harvested and grown without the need to slaughter animals, potentially meeting the ethical and procedural requirements of kosher and halal standards.
Allergen-Free and Hypoallergenic Meat: Some individuals have allergies to conventional meat products due to certain proteins. Through cellular agriculture, these allergens could potentially be removed or modified at the cellular level, producing a hypoallergenic meat product. This application could expand access to meat alternatives for consumers with specific food sensitivities.
Personalized Nutrition: As consumer interest in personalized nutrition grows, cellular agriculture offers a unique way to produce meat that caters to individual dietary preferences and health goals. For example, meat could be designed for athletes with optimized amino acid profiles for muscle recovery, or tailored for seniors with added nutrients to support bone and joint health.
4. Hybrid Meat Products
Cellular agriculture also has the potential to create hybrid products that combine cultured animal cells with plant-based ingredients, offering a middle ground between plant-based and cultured meat.
Improving Taste and Texture of Plant-Based Meat: By incorporating cultured animal cells into plant-based meat, hybrid products can achieve an even closer match to the taste, texture, and mouthfeel of conventional meat. For example, cultured fats or muscle cells can add the juiciness and fibrous texture that are difficult to achieve solely with plant ingredients. Hybrid products could appeal to consumers looking for a closer mimicry of meat while still reducing animal-based ingredients.
Enhanced Nutritional Profiles: Plant-based meats are generally rich in fiber and certain vitamins, while cultured animal cells provide high-quality protein and fats. Hybrid products could offer the best of both worlds, creating a nutritionally complete product that is both high in protein and rich in beneficial plant compounds like antioxidants.
Cost Reduction and Scalability: Hybrid products can also help reduce the cost of cultured meat by using plant-based components as fillers, lowering the reliance on expensive cell culture processes. This approach could make meat alternatives more affordable and accessible while retaining some of the sensory qualities of real meat.
5. Expanding Beyond Meat: Other Animal-Based Products
Cellular agriculture’s scope extends beyond meat to other animal-derived products such as milk, eggs, leather, and gelatin, addressing a wider range of applications in the food and textile industries.
Cultured Dairy and Eggs: Cellular agriculture techniques can produce milk and eggs without requiring cows or chickens. By cultivating mammary or egg-producing cells, scientists can generate animal proteins like casein, whey, and albumin that are identical to those in traditional dairy and eggs. These products could serve as alternatives to conventional dairy and egg products, with the potential to meet the demand for animal-free ingredients in baking, cooking, and food processing.
Lab-Grown Leather and Gelatin: Beyond food, cellular agriculture is exploring the production of materials like leather and gelatin in controlled lab environments. Lab-grown leather involves cultivating collagen-producing cells to create a product that mimics traditional leather without animal slaughter. Similarly, cultured gelatin can be produced by isolating collagen-producing cells, offering a more sustainable and ethical alternative for use in foods, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals.
6. Potential for Disease-Free and Antibiotic-Free Meat Production
One of the unique advantages of cellular agriculture is the ability to produce meat in a sterile environment, reducing the risk of disease transmission and eliminating the need for antibiotics.
Minimizing Zoonotic Disease Risk: Traditional animal farming can expose humans to zoonotic diseases that transfer from animals to humans, such as avian flu and swine flu. By eliminating the need to raise live animals, cellular agriculture significantly reduces the risk of zoonotic disease outbreaks, contributing to a safer food system.
Antibiotic-Free Production: Antibiotics are widely used in conventional farming to prevent infections in crowded and often unsanitary conditions. This overuse of antibiotics has been linked to the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, posing a serious public health threat. Cultured meat, grown in controlled, sterile environments, does not require antibiotics, addressing concerns around antibiotic resistance and promoting safer meat production.
5. Challenges and Future Prospects
A. Scaling Production and Reducing Costs
One of the primary challenges for cellular agriculture is achieving cost-effective scalability. While progress has been made in reducing production costs, cultured meat remains more expensive than traditional meat and plant-based alternatives. Improved bioreactor designs, economies of scale, and further research into cost-effective growth media are crucial to reducing prices.
B. Consumer Acceptance and Regulatory Approval
Widespread adoption of cultured meat depends on consumer acceptance and regulatory frameworks. While some consumers view lab-grown meat with skepticism, education and transparent communication about its benefits could shift perceptions. Regulatory bodies are also beginning to establish safety and labeling guidelines, but full-scale commercialization requires extensive testing to ensure safety.
C. Ethical and Environmental Considerations
While cellular agriculture addresses animal welfare concerns, it does not eliminate environmental impacts entirely. The energy required for bioreactors and cell culture processes can still be significant, and without sustainable energy sources, the environmental footprint may remain a concern. Furthermore, there are ethical debates about genetically modifying cells for food, though consumer perspectives vary widely.
6. The Future of Plant-Based and Cultured Meat
The rapid advancements in cellular agriculture and plant-based meat alternatives are paving the way for a new era in food production. Experts predict that the industry will see significant growth and diversification in the coming years, with plant-based and cultured meats becoming more common in grocery stores and restaurants globally.
The potential for combining plant-based ingredients with cultured cells is also being explored. This hybrid approach could create meat products that balance the environmental benefits of plant-based ingredients with the sensory qualities of real animal cells, potentially leading to a new category of “cultivated plant-based” meats.
Conclusion
The advances in cellular agriculture and plant-based meat alternatives highlight a promising shift toward sustainable food production. By reducing the need for animal agriculture, these technologies contribute to environmental conservation, animal welfare, and food security. Despite current challenges, the outlook for plant-based and cultured meats is optimistic. With continued innovation, consumer acceptance, and regulatory support, these alternatives may become mainstream, ultimately contributing to a more sustainable, ethical, and nutritious food system for future generations.
References:
- Bhat, Z. F., & Fayaz, H. (2011). “Prospects for In Vitro Cultured Meat: A Future Harvest.” Meat Science, 87(2), 148–156.
- Chriki, S., & Hocquette, J. F. (2020). “The Myth of Cultured Meat: A Review.” Frontiers in Nutrition, 7, 7.
- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). (2013). “Tackling Climate Change Through Livestock: A Global Assessment of Emissions and Mitigation Opportunities.” FAO.
- Loveday, S. M. (2019). “Plant Protein Ingredients with Functionality Beyond Nutrition.” Annual Review of Food Science and Technology, 10, 311-339.
- Post, M. J. (2014). “Cultured Beef: Medical Technology to Produce Food.” Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 94(6), 1039-1041.
- Rubio, N. R., et al. (2019). “Plant-Based and Cell-Based Approaches to Meat Production.” Nature Communications, 10(1), 1-11.
- Specht, E. A., et al. (2018). “Opportunities for Applying Biomedical Production and Manufacturing Methods to the Development of the Clean Meat Industry.” Biochemical Engineering Journal, 132, 161-168.
- Stephens, N., et al. (2018). “Bringing Cultured Meat to Market: Technical, Socio-Political, and Regulatory Challenges in Cellular Agriculture.” Trends in Food Science & Technology, 78, 155-166.
- Szejda, K., Urbanovich, T., & Wilks, M. (2020). “Accelerating Consumer Adoption of Plant-Based Meat: An Evidence-Based Guide for Effective Practice.” Good Food Institute.